Leeds vs Huddersfield MOTM

[1964white]

The non-love in for Rodon continues....

I can't recall Jamie making a goal-saving tackle, in fact Joe saved Shacks blushes.

Rodon had 36 positive actions more than treble Shacks contribution, with no mistakes/negatives in Rodon's game whatsoever!

Our best defender without a shadow of doubt, immense performance!

Our defence will cave in if he misses the Leicester game.

[whiteswan]

The non-love in for Rodon continues....

I can't recall Jamie making a goal-saving tackle, in fact Joe saved Shacks blushes.

Rodon had 36 positive actions more than treble Shacks contribution, with no mistakes/negatives in Rodon's game whatsoever!

Our best defender without a shadow of doubt, immense performance!

Our defence will cave in if he misses the Leicester game.

Maybe there were just too many excellent performances Leon....

[1964white]

Maybe there were just too many excellent performances Leon....

There were Swannie, but after viewing the game again, Rodon produced a perfect display whilst other around him made errors.

Byram & Struijk were above Shacks on my reckoning, so albeit Shacks having a decent game, I'm unsure why he was such a popular choice.

Rodon is our new Ben White, but certainly doesn't receive the same plaudits as the Arsenal star.

[1964white]

Maybe there were just too many excellent performances Leon....

Anyway my upcoming ratings will show how highly I rated Joe Rodon.

[andrewjohnsmith]

There were Swannie, but after viewing the game again, Rodon produced a perfect display whilst other around him made errors.

Byram & Struijk were above Shacks on my reckoning, so albeit Shacks having a decent game, I'm unsure why he was such a popular choice.

Rodon is our new Ben White, but certainly doesn't receive the same plaudits as the Arsenal star.

I didn't think Shackleton had a great game. He was off it in the first 20 minutes. But settled down later. I suppose he gets points for being able tp slot in and do a job at a number of positions. And for his energy and effort. I've had high hopes for Shacks ever since he broke in under Bielsa. But watching the Huddersfield game, I get the feeling that he probably won't develop into more than a championship squad player.

[andrewjohnsmith]

Summerville
Rutter
James
Strujik
Rodon
Kamara (coin flip between him , Byram and Ampadu for 6th spot)

[1964white]

I didn't think Shackleton had a great game. He was off it in the first 20 minutes. But settled down later. I suppose he gets points for being able tp slot in and do a job at a number of positions. And for his energy and effort. I've had high hopes for Shacks ever since he broke in under Bielsa. But watching the Huddersfield game, I get the feeling that he probably won't develop into more than a championship squad player.

Shacks played well & grew into the game, but he probably only bettered Meslier & our subs imo!

[Cjay]

There were Swannie, but after viewing the game again, Rodon produced a perfect display whilst other around him made errors.

Byram & Struijk were above Shacks on my reckoning, so albeit Shacks having a decent game, I'm unsure why he was such a popular choice.

Rodon is our new Ben White, but certainly doesn't receive the same plaudits as the Arsenal star.

I thought Shacks had a good game, had him basically in line with Byram, Rodon etc and was a coin toss between them in my top 6.

In hindsight maybe that tackle from Rodon edged it.

[1964white]

I thought Shacks had a good game, had him basically in line with Byram, Rodon etc and was a coin toss between them in my top 6.

In hindsight maybe that tackle from Rodon edged it.

More than just one sublime tackle, mate.

Roden had 36 decent actions of play, compared to 13 for Shacks. Jamie also made three errors, Joe was nigh on perfect.

If you have a peep on Twitter, I do a similar analysis to LUFCDATA - he has done stats on Summerville, James, Rutter, Kamara, Rodon, Ampadu, Byram & Struijk. No stats on Shackleton as there is clearly not enough in comparison to the eight I've mentioned.

[1964white]

So all the Shackleton voters not contesting my reasoning.

Sometimes it's like having a conversation with the man on the moon on here, unless it's with Geronimo

[The Subhuman]

So all the Shackleton voters not contesting my reasoning.

Sometimes it's like having a conversation with the man on the moon on here, unless it's with Geronimo

You really don't me to bite ...

[John in Louisiana]

Anyway my upcoming ratings will show how highly I rated Joe Rodon.

I rated him very highly as well (8.5/10 which is, in retrospect, probably a bit low). He dominated along the back. They never looked like scoring as long as Rodon was in the game.

We absolutely have to have him ready for Leicester if we're going to win.

[1964white]

I rated him very highly as well (8.5/10 which is, in retrospect, probably a bit low). He dominated along the back. They never looked like scoring as long as Rodon was in the game.

We absolutely have to have him ready for Leicester if we're going to win.

Indeed John we looked a little jittery with Ayling & Cooper in the back four, even though we were not under much pressure!

[1964white]

You really don't me to bite ...

You should do.

I'm surprised you called it wrong mate, unlike you!

[The Subhuman]

You should do.

I'm surprised you called it wrong mate, unlike you!

I didn't..Rodon played an hour scored an 8, Shack played 90 minutes in 2 different positions and got an 8, it's an opinion. I gave them both 8's

I stand by that, It's why Rutter got my MOTM because he was as influential as Cry but played further into the match

[1964white]

I didn't..Rodon played an hour scored an 8, Shack played 90 minutes in 2 different positions and got an 8, it's an opinion. I gave them both 8's

I stand by that, It's why Rutter got my MOTM because he was as influential as Cry but played further into the match

[1964white]

Huddersfield Town
87 Rutter
84 Summerville
62 James
43 Kamara
25 Ampadu
19 Rodon
10 Shackleton
04 Struijk
01 Piroe

Man Of The Match
Summerville (Cardiff)
Ampadu (Birmingham)
James (West Brom)
Rutter (Ipswich)
Shackleton (Salford
Gnonto (Sheff Wed)
Ampadu (Millwall)
Summerville (Hull City)
Rutter (Watford)
Struijk (Southampton)
Ampadu (QPR)
Rutter (Bristol City)
Summerville (Norwich City)
Rutter (Stoke City)
Rutter (Huddersfield Town)

Combined Total After Game 16
746 Ampadu
692 Rutter
594 Summerville
484 Struijk
399 Gray
361 Shackleton
300 James
285 Byram
243 Gnonto
211 Rodon
175 Piroe
128 Sinisterra
059 Anthony
094 Kamara
057 Meslier
041 Cooper
036 Cresswell
026 Ayling
009 Poveda
005 Spence
003 Gelhardt
001 Hjelde