Rate the ref: United V Boro 02/12/23

[1964white]

Bump

[mentalcase]

Rate the ref please, kick off 12.30.

Samuel Barrott

[mentalcase]

Best ref so far is :
Josh Smith , Cardiff game, with an average of 7.8 ( 11 voters )
Worst is :
M. Donohue, West brom game, average of 2 ( 13 voters )
J.Simpson , Watford game, average of 2.5 ( 8 voters )
S.Martin, Hull game, average of 3 ( only 4 voters )

[Jammy 07]

Referee was fine in a game without too much controversy.

6.5

[John in Louisiana]

Absolutely nothing to complain about from the ref, more's the pity.

7.5

[Jaydog]

5 average. Let a lot go for either team especially on Summerville

[Barlow Boy]

7

Can’t think of too many controversial moments.

[mentalcase]

5
Should have second yellowed that player for hitting Summerville, one day a ref will do his job properly, probably at our cost no doubt.

[1964white]

How many times was Summerville clattered? our little ones constantly fouled by bullies.

Smallbone should have walked, no he's given a reprieve & minute later he scores Saints second goal.

Different game with ten 10 vs 11

5/10

[1964white]

5
Should have second yellowed that player for hitting Summerville, one day a ref will do his job properly, probably at our cost no doubt.

Unfair decisions cost us at Hull & Southampton.

[mentalcase]

David Webb will be ref on Wednesday, never liked him since 1970 cup final.
David Webb
Avg. cards
Red: 0.14 Yellow : 3.14

[mentalcase]

Bump

[Byebyegeegee]

Can’t remember much that he did wrong from a Leeds United point of view. Lenient on QPR’s time wasting but that didn’t matter this time, because it was there own time they were wasting. A bit of controversy with the sending off which I’m sure most people other than Leeds fans will think he got wrong, but I’m not so sure - studs up and dangerous play by there keeper! Happily, it makes a nice change when a controversial incident actually is advantageous to Leeds United, although, having said that, it happened too late to have any significant affect on the outcome of the match. 8/10

[1964white]

My rating up later.

[mentalcase]

No point doing another

[whiteswan]

No point doing another

I think folk only like to rate a bad ref so they can have a good old moan mc

[1964white]

8/10

[Muppet the Cat]

No point doing another

MC, I ran this one a couple of seasons ago and it really is like extracting blood from a stone........so I know exactly how you feel.

Personally, I wouldn't blame you for giving up the ghost. IMO there just isn't the interest, unless as others have pointed out we have a ref, who has a complete mare.......and then everyone wants to unload on him.

[1964white]

No point doing another

Late with mine, but only two entries in is pathetic.

[1964white]

I think folk only like to rate a bad ref so they can have a good old moan mc

Win, lose or draw, not participating is an insult to the people who run our competitions.