Leeds vs Cardiff P. Ratings. Only 8 ratings after that sublime show.

[Cjay]

Plus any individual analysis

Meslier
Bogle
Firpo
Rodon
Ampadu
Tanaka
Rothwell
Aaronson
Solomon
James
Piroe



Joseph
Ramazani
Gnonto
Byram

[Cjay]

Meslier-7
Bogle-7
Firpo-9.5
Rodon-7
Ampadu-7
Tanaka-9
Rothwell-8.5
Aaronson-8.5
Solomon-9
James-9.5
Piroe-9.5



Joseph-8
Ramazani-7
Gnonto-7.5
Byram-7

[Tyzy]

Meslier-7
Bogle-8
Firpo-9
Rodon-8
Ampadu-8
Tanaka-8
Rothwell-8
Aaronson-8
Solomon-9
James-9
Piroe-8



Joseph-7
Ramazani-7
Gnonto-7
Byram-7

[The Subhuman]

Meslier - 7.5
Bogle - 7.5
Firpo - 9.5
Tanaka - 8
Rodon - 8
Ampadu - 7.5
James - 9
Rothwell - 7.5
Piroe - 9
Aaronson - 7.5
Solomon - 8.5

Gnonto - 7.5
Byram 6
Joseph - 7.5
Ramazani - 7

[andrewjohnsmith]

Meslier 8
Bogle 8
Firpo 9
Rodon 8
Ampadu 7 (not much to do)
Tanaka 8
Rothwell 7
Aaronson 8
Solomon 8
James 9
Piroe 8

Joseph 8
Ramazani 8
Gnonto 8
Byram 7

[John in Louisiana]

Meslier - 8
Bogle - 8
Firpo - 9.5
Tanaka - 8
Rodon - 8
Ampadu - 8
James - 9.5
Rothwell - 8
Piroe - 8.5
Aaronson - 8.5
Solomon - 8.5

Gnonto - 7.5
Byram 7
Joseph - 7.5
Ramazani - 7.5

Using 7 as good, 8 as very good, and 9 as excellent, it's impossible to see how anyone in the starting eleven merits less than an 8. The subs, too, although they get knocked a half a point for having played fewer minutes.

[Cowboy Dan]

Meslier - 7
Bogle - 7.5
Firpo - 9
Rodon - 7.5
Ampadu - 7
Tanaka - 8
Rothwell - 7
Aaronson - 7
Solomon - 7.5
James - 9
Piroe - 8.5



Joseph-7
Ramazani-7
Gnonto-7.5
Byram-6.5

[JoeDenver]

Meslier-7
Bogle-7
Firpo-9.5
Rodon-7
Ampadu-7
Tanaka-9
Rothwell-8.5
Aaronson-8
Solomon-9
James-9.5
Piroe-9



Joseph-8
Ramazani-7
Gnonto-8
Byram-7

Hard to give a bad rating to anyone! Great team performance!

[1964white]

Any more ratings please?

[1964white]

7 Meslier
7 Bogle
9.5 Firpo
8.5 Tanaka
8 Rodon
8 Ampadu
9.5 James
9 Rothwell
9.5 Piroe
7.5 Aaronson
8 Solomon

7.5 Gnonto
7 Joseph
7 Ramazani
n/a Byram
n/a Struijk

[andrewjohnsmith]

I think you need to consider eliminating the MOTM thread. Or this one. One probably distracts from the other.

[1964white]

I think you need to consider eliminating the MOTM thread. Or this one. One probably distracts from the other.

You are probably right, Andrew.

[Musicman1965]

Meslier 7 - Made 1 good save but mainly the ball was up the other end, so no 8 rating
Bogle 8
Firpo 9.5 MOTM imo, best player on the park by a country mile
Rodon 8
Ampadu 8
Tanaka 8.5 The usually quality
Rothwell 8.5
Aaronson 8.5 Played well, great team performamce
Solomon 8.5 Class Aact
James 9.0 How Dan James has improved is great to see, the first set up was a good example
Piroe 9.0 He had a great game played so well and his forward passing was excellent, took his goal well

Joseph 8 When he gets the right ball played he is on the end of it.
Ramazani 8 Played well, was unlucky not to get on the score sheet
Gnonto Glad he scored, he needs the confidence boost.

[CUSSIE01]

Meslier 7.5
Bogle 7.5
Firpo 9
Rodon 8.5
Ampadu 8
Tanaka 8.5
Rothwell 8
Aaronson 8.5
Solomon 9
James 9.5
Piroe 9



Joseph 7.5
Ramazani 7
Gnonto 7.5
Byram 7

[Johnthewhite]

Meslier- 7 - One good save and one good interception
Bogle- 8 - So good going forward
Firpo- 9 - Had a great game, its good to see as let's be honest he's had his problems going the other way.
Rodon - 9 - He was fabulous all afternoon, snuffed out any threats early doors
Ampadu - 8 - Always looked in control, one or two stray passes.
Tanaka - 9 - Looks a league above (which hopefully will come in handy)
Rothwell - 8 - Provides great energy going forward, a few decent set pieces too.
Aaronson - 8 - Getting more consistent, hope it continues.
Solomon - 9 - Showing his class now, if we can keep him and DJ fit I think we go up as Champions
James - 9 - Quality
Piroe - 8 - Better player when we push on and play on the front foot

Joseph - 7 - So glad he got his goal, let's hope that's the start of a run now
Ramazani- 7 - Looked very lively and unlucky not to get a goal, looking forward to seeing more minutes for him against Millwall.
Gnonto - 7 - Great run and finish for his goal, needs to take his chance against Millwall.
Byram - 7 -Steady enough

[Jammy 07]

Meslier 7.5
Bogle 8
Rodon 8
Ampedu 7.5
Firpo 9
Tanaka 8
Rothwell 8
Aaronson 8
Solomon 9
James 9
Piroe 8.5

Gnonto 8
Byram 7
Joseph 7.5
Ramazani 7.5
Srtuijk 7