Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Meslier
Ayling
Cooper
Struijk
Dallas
Koch
Klich
Rodrigo
Raphinha
Bamford
Harrison
subs
Firpo
Costa
Roberts
Ayling
Cooper
Struijk
Dallas
Koch
Klich
Rodrigo
Raphinha
Bamford
Harrison
subs
Firpo
Costa
Roberts
- The Subhuman
- Superstar
- Posts: 55508
- Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 am
- Location: God's own county
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Meslier - 7, Kept us in it and not to blame for the goals bar maybe the first
Ayling - 8 - Cracking goal
Cooper - 4 - Poor
Struijk - 5 - Poor but out of position
Koch - 5 - Going to need more time there or play him at CB
Dallas - 7 - Difficult mid game change yet again. Got an Assist
Klich - 8 - Good game, faded as Manure took control
Raphinha - 5 - A shocker for him, too many passes go wayward
Harrison - 6 - Quiet
Rodrigo - 6 - Still not a ten, maybe a season away?
Bamford - 5 - Poor I thought, control was off, got bullied a bit too easily
Firpo - 6 - Debut, will need time obviousy
Costa - 6 Came on wrong side for me
Roberts - 8 - Set up Raph beautifully, unlucky to not get an assist. Not long enough on the pitch
Marcelo Bielsa - 5 - Got it wrong today selection wise, out thought by OGS
Ayling - 8 - Cracking goal
Cooper - 4 - Poor
Struijk - 5 - Poor but out of position
Koch - 5 - Going to need more time there or play him at CB
Dallas - 7 - Difficult mid game change yet again. Got an Assist
Klich - 8 - Good game, faded as Manure took control
Raphinha - 5 - A shocker for him, too many passes go wayward
Harrison - 6 - Quiet
Rodrigo - 6 - Still not a ten, maybe a season away?
Bamford - 5 - Poor I thought, control was off, got bullied a bit too easily
Firpo - 6 - Debut, will need time obviousy
Costa - 6 Came on wrong side for me
Roberts - 8 - Set up Raph beautifully, unlucky to not get an assist. Not long enough on the pitch
Marcelo Bielsa - 5 - Got it wrong today selection wise, out thought by OGS
"Never debate an idiot, they'll only drag you down to their level and they have the advantage of experience"
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Meslier - 7, Not much he could do with any of them
Ayling - 4 - goal dosnt save him, poor for me.
Cooper - 4 - terrible
Struijk - 5 - Tried his best but average. Much better with Llorente
Koch - 3 - awful we have no replacement for Phillips
Dallas - 5 not a great second half
Klich - 6 tried to get things going but not good enough.
Raphinha - 3 worst performance yet. Gave the ball away and should of scored.
Harrison - 6 - Bot bad first half, anonymous second half
Rodrigo - 4 clear it’s not his position, should of touted him around Europe this summer.
Bamford - 5 did what he could, no service looked frustrated.
Ayling - 4 - goal dosnt save him, poor for me.
Cooper - 4 - terrible
Struijk - 5 - Tried his best but average. Much better with Llorente
Koch - 3 - awful we have no replacement for Phillips
Dallas - 5 not a great second half
Klich - 6 tried to get things going but not good enough.
Raphinha - 3 worst performance yet. Gave the ball away and should of scored.
Harrison - 6 - Bot bad first half, anonymous second half
Rodrigo - 4 clear it’s not his position, should of touted him around Europe this summer.
Bamford - 5 did what he could, no service looked frustrated.
- White Riot
- Superstar
- Posts: 15914
- Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2019 2:02 pm
- Location: Plovdiv, Bulgaria
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Easy this time mate = 0 for the lot of them
-
- Youth Team
- Posts: 235
- Joined: Thu Jan 11, 2018 1:23 pm
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Roberts - 8! I want whatever you're drinking or smoking as I don't think he's worthy of 8 in any game he's played for Leeds (maybe Huddersfield), never mind one where we've been embarrassed!faaip wrote: ↑Sat Aug 14, 2021 1:37 pm Meslier - 7, Kept us in it and not to blame for the goals bar maybe the first
Ayling - 8 - Cracking goal
Cooper - 4 - Poor
Struijk - 5 - Poor but out of position
Koch - 5 - Going to need more time there or play him at CB
Dallas - 7 - Difficult mid game change yet again. Got an Assist
Klich - 8 - Good game, faded as Manure took control
Raphinha - 5 - A shocker for him, too many passes go wayward
Harrison - 6 - Quiet
Rodrigo - 6 - Still not a ten, maybe a season away?
Bamford - 5 - Poor I thought, control was off, got bullied a bit too easily
Roberts - 8! I want whatever you're drinking or smoking. I wouldn't give him an 8 for any game he's played for Leeds!
Firpo - 6 - Debut, will need time obviousy
Costa - 6 Came on wrong side for me
Roberts - 8 - Set up Raph beautifully, unlucky to not get an assist. Not long enough on the pitch
Marcelo Bielsa - 5 - Got it wrong today selection wise, out thought by OGS
Last edited by MightyWhites on Sat Aug 14, 2021 3:43 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- andrewjohnsmith
- Site Contributor
- Posts: 7854
- Joined: Sat Feb 03, 2018 4:58 pm
- Location: California (Donny Born-n-Bred)
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Meslier 6
Ayling 6
Cooper 4
Struijk 5
Dallas 5
Koch 5
Klich 6
Rodrigo 4
Raphinha
Bamford 5
Harrison 5
subs
Firpo 5
Costa 5
Roberts 5
Ayling 6
Cooper 4
Struijk 5
Dallas 5
Koch 5
Klich 6
Rodrigo 4
Raphinha
Bamford 5
Harrison 5
subs
Firpo 5
Costa 5
Roberts 5
- The Subhuman
- Superstar
- Posts: 55508
- Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 10:03 am
- Location: God's own county
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Never smoked anything my entire 60 years, nor taken any sort of illegal drug .. and TeaMightyWhites wrote: ↑Sat Aug 14, 2021 3:40 pm Roberts - 8! I want whatever you're drinking or smoking as I don't think he's worthy of 8 in any game he's played for Leeds (maybe Huddersfield), never mind one where we've been embarrassed!
Hope that helps...
"Never debate an idiot, they'll only drag you down to their level and they have the advantage of experience"
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Sorry these ratings are so off the mark it's unbelievablefaaip wrote: ↑Sat Aug 14, 2021 1:37 pm Meslier - 7, Kept us in it and not to blame for the goals bar maybe the first
Ayling - 8 - Cracking goal
Cooper - 4 - Poor
Struijk - 5 - Poor but out of position
Koch - 5 - Going to need more time there or play him at CB
Dallas - 7 - Difficult mid game change yet again. Got an Assist
Klich - 8 - Good game, faded as Manure took control
Raphinha - 5 - A shocker for him, too many passes go wayward
Harrison - 6 - Quiet
Rodrigo - 6 - Still not a ten, maybe a season away?
Bamford - 5 - Poor I thought, control was off, got bullied a bit too easily
Firpo - 6 - Debut, will need time obviousy
Costa - 6 Came on wrong side for me
Roberts - 8 - Set up Raph beautifully, unlucky to not get an assist. Not long enough on the pitch
Marcelo Bielsa - 5 - Got it wrong today selection wise, out thought by OGS
- Johnboy1965
- Subs Bench
- Posts: 812
- Joined: Wed Apr 28, 2021 7:53 am
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Meslier 5
Ayling 6
Cooper 3
Struijk 3
Dallas 3
Koch 2
Klich 5
Rodrigo 1
Raphinha 3
Bamford 3
Harrison 3
subs
Firpo 3
Costa 2
Roberts 3
Ayling 6
Cooper 3
Struijk 3
Dallas 3
Koch 2
Klich 5
Rodrigo 1
Raphinha 3
Bamford 3
Harrison 3
subs
Firpo 3
Costa 2
Roberts 3
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Meslier 7
Ayling 6.5
Cooper 6.5
Struijk 6
Dallas 6.5
Koch 4.5
Klich 7
Rodrigo 3.5
Raphinha 5.5
Bamford 5.5
Harrison 4.5
subs
Firpo 6
Costa 3
Roberts 5.5
Ayling 6.5
Cooper 6.5
Struijk 6
Dallas 6.5
Koch 4.5
Klich 7
Rodrigo 3.5
Raphinha 5.5
Bamford 5.5
Harrison 4.5
subs
Firpo 6
Costa 3
Roberts 5.5
-
- Reserve Player
- Posts: 351
- Joined: Tue Aug 10, 2021 3:04 pm
Re: Manchester United v Leeds United - 5-1 - MOTM
Everyone gets a 3 for showing up to the ground, add a couple of points to Ayling for the worldie.
Raphinha had a particularly bad bad game.
Meslier - bad distribution and could’ve saved a couple.
Cooper -no leadership at all
Struijk - should’ve taken a yellow for the 2nd goal, that changed the entire game
Koch - out of position but he’s an international caliber footballer and should demonstrate better game awareness
Ayling - some bad passes, but the goal was top drawer, drop the hair play the guitar class
Dallas - warrior, probably the one with the least amount of mistakes
Klich - anonymous apart from that one shot from outside the box
Raphinha - the worst I’ve seen him play, hopefully brings his head space back to Mother Earth
Harrison - a couple of bad first touches, unlike JH
Rodrigo - ditto Klich, except he missed a header that should’ve been on target
Costa - needs to be sold, even if for just 5M
Roberts - little time but should’ve taken his chance than go down
Firpo - debut, gets a pass
Raphinha had a particularly bad bad game.
Meslier - bad distribution and could’ve saved a couple.
Cooper -no leadership at all
Struijk - should’ve taken a yellow for the 2nd goal, that changed the entire game
Koch - out of position but he’s an international caliber footballer and should demonstrate better game awareness
Ayling - some bad passes, but the goal was top drawer, drop the hair play the guitar class
Dallas - warrior, probably the one with the least amount of mistakes
Klich - anonymous apart from that one shot from outside the box
Raphinha - the worst I’ve seen him play, hopefully brings his head space back to Mother Earth
Harrison - a couple of bad first touches, unlike JH
Rodrigo - ditto Klich, except he missed a header that should’ve been on target
Costa - needs to be sold, even if for just 5M
Roberts - little time but should’ve taken his chance than go down
Firpo - debut, gets a pass
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
6 Meslier
6 Ayling
3 Cooper
3 Struijk
5 Dallas
2 Koch
6 Klich
1 Rodrigo
4 Raphinha
2 Bamford
3 Harrison
subs
3 Firpo
1 Costa
4 Roberts
6 Ayling
3 Cooper
3 Struijk
5 Dallas
2 Koch
6 Klich
1 Rodrigo
4 Raphinha
2 Bamford
3 Harrison
subs
3 Firpo
1 Costa
4 Roberts
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
What is your Raphinha score Andrew?andrewjohnsmith wrote: ↑Sat Aug 14, 2021 3:41 pm Meslier 6
Ayling 6
Cooper 4
Struijk 5
Dallas 5
Koch 5
Klich 6
Rodrigo 4
Raphinha
Bamford 5
Harrison 5
subs
Firpo 5
Costa 5
Roberts 5
- mentalcase
- Moderator
- Posts: 7045
- Joined: Sun Aug 08, 2021 3:19 pm
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
Bielsa - 10 for his staggering arrogance
When he gets it right it normally goes well
When he gets it wrong, he gets it staggeringly wrong
If youre ever going to get embarrassed, never do it against your most hated rivals, fat argies know nothing about our rivalry.
His arrogance will be his undoing.
When he gets it right it normally goes well
When he gets it wrong, he gets it staggeringly wrong
If youre ever going to get embarrassed, never do it against your most hated rivals, fat argies know nothing about our rivalry.
His arrogance will be his undoing.
"Critics are men that watch a battle from a high place, then come down and shoot the survivors"
- White Riot
- Superstar
- Posts: 15914
- Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2019 2:02 pm
- Location: Plovdiv, Bulgaria
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
mentalcase wrote: ↑Sat Aug 14, 2021 7:10 pm Bielsa - 10 for his staggering arrogance
When he gets it right it normally goes well
When he gets it wrong, he gets it staggeringly wrong
If youre ever going to get embarrassed, never do it against your most hated rivals, fat argies know nothing about our rivalry.
His arrogance will be his undoing.
Don't beat about the bush MC just say it as it is mate.
I share your frustration, can't believe what I witnessed against Scum last season and then fookin same again today
- Muppet the Cat
- Moderator
- Posts: 13044
- Joined: Mon May 29, 2017 9:42 pm
- Location: Cardiff
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
I share your frustration today MC, at was by any means a disappointing score-line.mentalcase wrote: ↑Sat Aug 14, 2021 7:10 pm Bielsa - 10 for his staggering arrogance
When he gets it right it normally goes well
When he gets it wrong, he gets it staggeringly wrong
If youre ever going to get embarrassed, never do it against your most hated rivals, fat argies know nothing about our rivalry.
His arrogance will be his undoing.
But based on one game, those comments show a staggering lack of disrespect for a man who has done so much for Leeds and put us back at the top table of the game.
- andrewjohnsmith
- Site Contributor
- Posts: 7854
- Joined: Sat Feb 03, 2018 4:58 pm
- Location: California (Donny Born-n-Bred)
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a) ANYMORE RATINGS?
Pfft i dont know, tempted to give them all a 1.
But.
Meslier-5
Ayling-3 (he gets one for the goal, defensively appalling).
Struijk-4
Cooper-4
Dallas-3
Koch-2
Raph-3
Harrison-3
Klich-4
Rodders-1
Bamford-4
Firpo-4
Costa-1
Roberts-4
But.
Meslier-5
Ayling-3 (he gets one for the goal, defensively appalling).
Struijk-4
Cooper-4
Dallas-3
Koch-2
Raph-3
Harrison-3
Klich-4
Rodders-1
Bamford-4
Firpo-4
Costa-1
Roberts-4
Signed
King Cjay
Fountain of all knowledge and wisdom
King Cjay
Fountain of all knowledge and wisdom
Re: Player Ratings v Manure (a)
8 ratings
5.8 - 46.0 Meslier
5.6 - 45.0 Klich
5.6 - 44.5 Ayling
4.9 - 37.5 Dallas
4.6 - 32.5 Roberts (sub -7 ratings)
4.3 - 34.0 Struijk
4.3 - 30.0 Firpo (sub - 7 ratings)
4.2 - 33.5 Harrison
4.1 - 32.5 Bamford
3.9 - 31.5 Cooper
3.6 - 28.5 Raphinha
3.3 - 26.5 Koch
3.0 - 21.0 Costa (sub -7 ratings)
2.9 - 23.5 Rodrigo
Raters : Andrew, Canuck, Cjay, Faaip, Johnboy, LUFC66, White Riot, Whiterose
5.8 - 46.0 Meslier
5.6 - 45.0 Klich
5.6 - 44.5 Ayling
4.9 - 37.5 Dallas
4.6 - 32.5 Roberts (sub -7 ratings)
4.3 - 34.0 Struijk
4.3 - 30.0 Firpo (sub - 7 ratings)
4.2 - 33.5 Harrison
4.1 - 32.5 Bamford
3.9 - 31.5 Cooper
3.6 - 28.5 Raphinha
3.3 - 26.5 Koch
3.0 - 21.0 Costa (sub -7 ratings)
2.9 - 23.5 Rodrigo
Raters : Andrew, Canuck, Cjay, Faaip, Johnboy, LUFC66, White Riot, Whiterose