Tyler Roberts-Birmingham move confirmed

[BGwhite]

I'm really looking forward to seeing his improvement....if it ever happens

Sent from my moto g(9) plus using Tapatalk

[The Subhuman]

Good game from him today, wins a lot of fouls, a couple of dodgy passes and a mis hit shot which we also saw from Raph, but a good game overall .. Great movement and held the ball up well when needed

[Byebyegeegee]

I respect your opinion faaip and appreciate that you are doing your best to convince us that Roberts is good enough, but sometimes I think you are watching a different game to me. A couple of dodgy passes and a miss hit shot about sums up his game today and most times I see him play.

He was shown up good and proper today by Gelhardt who, in my opinion, managed to do more in half an hour than Roberts has managed to do all season.

[andrewjohnsmith]

I respect your opinion faaip and appreciate that you are doing your best to convince us that Roberts is good enough, but sometimes I think you are watching a different game to me. A couple of dodgy passes and a miss hit shot about sums up his game today and most times I see him play.

He was shown up good and proper today by Gelhardt who, in my opinion, managed to do more in half an hour than Roberts has managed to do all season.

I keep defending Roberts. In his sub appearances over the past year he's shown flashes of promise. Athletically he's great. But this season he's had a few chances and never made any kind of impact. Wholly agree today that Gelhardt showed way more and now deserves to start up front in Bamford's absence.

[BGwhite]

I respect your opinion faaip and appreciate that you are doing your best to convince us that Roberts is good enough, but sometimes I think you are watching a different game to me. A couple of dodgy passes and a miss hit shot about sums up his game today and most times I see him play.

He was shown up good and proper today by Gelhardt who, in my opinion, managed to do more in half an hour than Roberts has managed to do all season.

Couldn't agree more, his progress is freighteningly snail paced , "there's a player in there somewhere" ...in the pub league.

Sent from my moto g(9) plus using Tapatalk

[Cjay]

I thought Roberts did better today than usual.

I appreciated his bravery when he risked his own safety to try and get James through, didnt quite work but he did win a freekick.

I liked him trying to gee up the crowd which cant be easy when he must know he isnt exactly Mr popular atm.

Made a good run and had a flicked header effort go just wide and he created 1 or 2 shooting opportunities for others.

By past standards i felt he was better today and was quite brave and positive at times.

The downside of course is he was sloppy with the ball on a few occasions (really sloppy passing it out of play when a simple pass was on).

And he was very overshadowed by his two other sub teammates in Summerville and Gelhardt (especially Gelhardt who is his direct competition for striker and AM role).

Better imo from Roberts overall but vastly overshadowed by his direct competition.

[mentalcase]

Gotta say his time on t' pitch today was his best in 12 months, but it was still poor.
To say he did well with a header and a flick and a pass and geeing up the crowd, well, quite frankly, every player should be able to do exactly that, they train long and hard and we are supposed to be impressed because they win a header ffs.
Roberts is shite and won't get any better, he's had his chance, far too many, MB has loyally stood by him, and others, and it's time to say Adios, cheerio, Auf wiedershein, off ya pop, beat it sonny, ta-ra, we'll ring you.
Maybe a loan will do him good, the kids far too lightweight and has no confidence.

[SG90]

Gotta say his time on t' pitch today was his best in 12 months, but it was still poor.
To say he did well with a header and a flick and a pass and geeing up the crowd, well, quite frankly, every player should be able to do exactly that, they train long and hard and we are supposed to be impressed because they win a header ffs.
Roberts is shite and won't get any better, he's had his chance, far too many, MB has loyally stood by him, and others, and it's time to say Adios, cheerio, Auf wiedershein, off ya pop, beat it sonny, ta-ra, we'll ring you.
Maybe a loan will do him good, the kids far too lightweight and has no confidence.

If 4 years with Bielsa won't improve him, how would a loan to the Championship? Time to get rid, he's had more than enough chances.

[BGwhite]

The championship ? ..... I was thinking The George &Dragon or The Red Lion , there's gotta be one of those somewhere willing to give him a trial.

Sent from my moto g(9) plus using Tapatalk

[mentalcase]

The championship ? ..... I was thinking The George &Dragon or The Red Lion , there's gotta be one of those somewhere willing to give him a trial.

Sent from my moto g(9) plus using Tapatalk

If it wasn't for Bielsa' loyalty, the kid would probably have faded into obscurity.
His future isn't at ER, even Bielsa must recognise that after today, he didn't start him, which was a suprise, and when he came on he was ineffective again, unless you count geeing the crowd up.
The young kids showed him what hunger is all about.

[The Subhuman]

I keep defending Roberts. In his sub appearances over the past year he's shown flashes of promise. Athletically he's great. But this season he's had a few chances and never made any kind of impact. Wholly agree today that Gelhardt showed way more and now deserves to start up front in Bamford's absence.

As he should, in fact I don't rate Bamford at all and that 30 minutes also showed up Bamford's very poor season thus far so Geldhardt over Bamford also. Roberts though is a midfielder now so they could play in the same team if needed..

[Byebyegeegee]

As he should, in fact I don't rate Bamford at all and that 30 minutes also showed up Bamford's very poor season thus far so Geldhardt over Bamford also. Roberts though is a midfielder now so they could play in the same team if needed..

Nice try again faaip but on today’s showing, in my opinion, Roberts is now behind Bamford and Gelhardt as a striker, behind Rodrigo and possibly Raphinha as a creative attacking midfielder and behind Raphinha and Summerville as a right winger.

[danhirons]

Joffy sure showed Roberts what he should be doing today! Another lacklustre performance from Tyler, few good flicks but lacked anything of any real contribution or substance

[Cjay]

From today's press conference

[1964white]

Bielsa & our board, obviously making plans for at least one incoming signing during January.

[White Riot]

Bielsa & our board, obviously making plans for at least one incoming signing during January.

I hope so, John Swift please

[1964white]

I hope so, John Swift please

No smoke without fire

Swift or O'Brien, maybe both.

[mentalcase]

Get roberts off the wage bill.

[The Subhuman]

Good player Roberts.

[mentalcase]

Aye he's proving that like.