Please be sure you are acquainted with the forum rules outlined within our FAQs.
Traditionalists argue a manager should be in charge of everything.
"Sack Orta" they cry.
But isnt that just hanging on to the past?
Similar to how our fans seem to want ageing English managers, Sam Allardyce, Mick McCarthy etc.
"Big Sam would never work under a DOF".
But he did at Everton, Steve Walsh.
Mick McCarthy to, Dave Bowman.
In fact most clubs in the premier league have a Director of Football, maybe not in name but the duties match whatever the title.
Marina Granovskaia - Chelsea, "she is mainly responsible for player transactions" a line from the Chelsea website.
She isnt called a Director of Football, but her role is similar to what most people assume a DOF does.
Les Reed -Southampton.
Txiki Begiristain-Manchester City.
There's others, but Director of Footballs do have there uses.
Ask Pep where he'd be without his close friend and Director of Football?
Thats the key though imo.
DOFs and Managers or Head Coaches or whatever, they have to be on the same page.
I dont think ours are.
Victor Orta and Paul Heckingbottom, you couldn't get 2 more different people.
One learned his trade at a Spanish giant under a scouting legend. The other is a lower league player from Barnsley.
We have already seen disagreement between the two.
Hecky wanted Andy Yiadom and wants Oli McBurnie. This is factual according to respected journalists.
Orta and Leeds didnt want Yiadom, they refused to go in for him.
And McBurnie is at best a back up option for the club, Hecky's preferred choice.
Hecky talked about wanting to build a team in "his image".
But that doesnt match up with the visions of DOF Victor Orta (and Owner Radz).
Hecky is a traditionalist, you only have to listen to him to know that, second balls, fighting and passion and all that.
He is in the mould of the aforementioned Sam and Mick.
He like good ole grit, ger it forward etc etc.
That isnt the remit Orta has from the top, thats not the type of player he is after.
And alas this is where problems begin.
A DOF and Manager with different visions, until one of them goes or changes we wont move forward.
Orta isnt going anywhere, he is here whether we like it or not.
At least he has some proven record in this league, Traore, Forshaw, Gestede, Rhodes, Ramirez, Bamford, all decent proven players at this level.
Dont want a yes man, of course not, but thats what we have now.
Id rather a manager who will stand up to Orta.
For that we need a decent name in there own right.
DOF isnt the problem, its conflicting ideas.
Knowing what we do know about the club refusing Heck's targets how can he stay and maintain the respect of the players?
- Posts: 7232
- Joined: Mon Aug 01, 2011 1:40 pm
- Twitter: @DrGonzo2411
- Location: Lisburn, N.I
P.S faaip, Stoke have just signed Rowett, so he ain't coming. Shame, I'd have liked him here too